1 July 2009 - 1:23pm| by | 8 comments

ASA bans Priest and Nun 'Kiss Temptation' Antonio Federici Ice Cream ad

ASA bans Priest and Nun 'Kiss Temptation' Antonio Federici Ice Cream adASA bans Priest and Nun 'Kiss Temptation' Antonio Federici Ice Cream

An advert suggesting a kiss between a Priest and a Nun has been banned following 10 complaints from people who felt it was offensive to the Catholic religion.

The images featured as part of a campaign for Antonio Federici Gelato Italiano ice cream and were photographed by Manchester based agency Contrast Creative’s photography division, High Contrast, alongside the client’s creative director Matt O’Connor.

High Contrast also provided the models, props and styling for the campaign which ran in across the food press in March.

Federici defended the ad, saying that it was intended as a light-hearted, tongue in cheek portrayal celebrating forbidden Italian temptations which Gelato Italiano ice cream represented.  

The client said that it considered that, in an age where religion was frequently used in a humorous way in the media, it would not offend the vast majority of readers. They felt this was borne out by the small number of complaints received. 

They considered the ad was unlikely to offend deeply a minority of people. In their view, there was nothing in the ad that was likely to cause either serious or widespread offence.

Antonio Federici also said it the priest and nun were not touching, meaning that it was left to readers to decide on what was happening and that the complaints were more about the implication of the adverts, rather than the adverts themselves.

Despite this, the Advertising Standard Authority (ASA) has upheld complains and said that it breached the decent Code.

It’s assessment read:  “The ASA noted the ad played on the theme of giving into temptation but stopped short of showing the nun and priest kissing.  The ad stated "KISS TEMPTATION" and the two were portrayed in a seductive pose, as if they were about to kiss passionately.

“We considered that the portrayal of the priest and nun in a sexualised manner and the implication that they were considering whether or not to give in to temptation, was likely to cause serious offence to some readers.”

Comments

Anonymous (not verified)
1 Jul 2009 - 13:54
Anonymous's picture

Should have been banned just for being an incredibly rubbish ad.

Anonymous (not verified)
1 Jul 2009 - 14:00
Anonymous's picture

Agreed.
Offends deeply for being shit.

1 Jul 2009 - 14:28
chris_miller's picture
101
comments
Anonymous (not verified)
1 Jul 2009 - 14:47
Anonymous's picture

This is wrong on so many levels. Only thing that seems true to life is the homoerotic art direction.

Anonymous (not verified)
1 Jul 2009 - 16:09
Anonymous's picture

What on earth are they trying to prove with this embarassment of an ad'.
If they're trying to get everyone talking they certainly have but for all the wrong reasons.

Anonymous (not verified)
1 Jul 2009 - 17:05
Anonymous's picture

The 48-sheet featuring a priest and a choirboy is much better.

Anonymous (not verified)
2 Jul 2009 - 12:26
Anonymous's picture

The trouble with the Catholic Church lodging a complaint about this ad', is with the present Pope being an ex member of the Hitler Youth, they tend to loose the moral high ground a little.

Anonymous (not verified)
17 Sep 2010 - 13:19
Anonymous's picture

With these rulings, the ASA is starting to look a bit silly. This is 2010, and what religious people have to understand, is that whilst they have a right to be offended, the rest of us have a right to not give a damn.
I suppose the ASA could have banned it under the 'not realistic' argument - it should feature a priest and a small boy!

Write Your Comment

New to The Drum

You will be sent a verification email. Click on the link in the email to post your comment.

Tick to receive daily newsletter full of the latest news in creative marketing and media.
By checking this box you are agreeing to The Drum's website terms and conditions.

Don't miss out... Get your Advertising news by email

Directory Latest