15 April 2010 - 11:07am| by | 22 comments

Creative bosses 'negative' according to survey

Creative bosses 'negative' according to surveyCreative bosses 'negative' according to survey

Almost 60 percent of the UK's creative industries workforce think the dominant management style within their organisation is negative, according to research by the Chartered Management Industry.

A survey of 5,000 people found the three most common management styles within creative industries' workplaces to be authoritarian (22 percent), reactive (22 per cent) and bureaucratic (15 per cent). Only 6.5 percent describe their bosses as innovative and just four percent think senior staff within their organisation are trusting.

Ruth Spellman, chief executive of CMI, said: "It is an embarrassment for the creative industries that 59 per cent of companies’ management style is seen to be negative by the people that know them best – their employees. And in case bosses think this doesn’t matter as long as they are turning a profit, think again.

"Goodwill and engagement among employees doesn’t only improve people’s working lives but it adds to the bottom line – in productivity, retention rates and customer loyalty. Negativity breeds negativity and if we are serious about pushing the UK towards economic recovery, we need more businesses that are innovative, accessible and empowering.”

CMI also asked people working in the creative industries to consider who, among those key figures vying for votes in the forthcoming general election, they would rather be managed by.

David Cameron was the most popular choice, for more than a third of those asked (48 percent) with Nick Clegg in second, securing support from 20 percent, closely followed by Gordon Brown with 17 percent and Caroline Lucas (15 per cent).

Comments

Anonymous (not verified)
15 Apr 2010 - 12:17
Anonymous's picture

Try being a boss then you will understand why!!!

Anonymous (not verified)
15 Apr 2010 - 12:26
Anonymous's picture

can you elaborate on this anon 12:17?

'understand why'....?

Anonymous (not verified)
15 Apr 2010 - 12:28
Anonymous's picture

Anon 12:17

If you feel that being; authoritarian, reactive and bureaucratic is the only way you can be 'a boss' then perhaps you should consider not being a boss??

Anonymous (not verified)
15 Apr 2010 - 12:59
Anonymous's picture

The skills required to generate great creative ideas are not always the same as those required to look after and nurture people trying to do exactly the same thing. Creative directors tend to have been there and done it which is why they got where they got. Doesn't in any way qualify them to teach, encourage, put their own agendas to one side. Those skills are very different and I think they take time to learn. On the way expect a whole load of shouting, control freakery, idea nicking shenanigans...

Anonymous (not verified)
15 Apr 2010 - 13:32
Anonymous's picture

My personal opinion is that management styles vary greatly depending on what type of person the 'the boss' is. The biggest problem associated with senior management/directors is the ability to understand that suggestions,ideas etc put forward by employees are there to help grow and sustain the agencies targets and aspirations - too many directors view these from a 'negative' viewpoint and take a linear thought process rather than a holistic approach to an idea or concept
but then again, they are management so....

Anonymous (not verified)
15 Apr 2010 - 13:37
Anonymous's picture

Authoritarian styles - that'll be the Southern prima donnas moving north..

Anonymous (not verified)
15 Apr 2010 - 13:44
Anonymous's picture

Well put 13:32..

Also, I think that if 'the boss' is actually a 'creative' and not just someone out to make a fast buck - one minute renting property the next 'digital media solutions' -that they understand the whole design process much better and can measure success not just in pounds, shillings and pence but can actually see a bigger picture...

I don't expect hard nosed, narrow minded out for themselves types of business people to understand this...

Anonymous (not verified)
15 Apr 2010 - 13:45
Anonymous's picture

Can anyone think of past employers that fit the bill...

Anon button very handy!

Anonymous (not verified)
15 Apr 2010 - 13:52
Anonymous's picture

all that happens with 'bosses' with this style is that they can't keep good staff and never really develop a team.

Anonymous (not verified)
15 Apr 2010 - 17:18
Anonymous's picture

Typical. Most people in the creative industry blame everyone but themselves for being negative..

Anonymous (not verified)
15 Apr 2010 - 21:39
Anonymous's picture

All this spats of a big gay gaggle of bitter losers who are never destined to be anything other than that miserable creative in the corner who never amounts to anything - you know who you are...

Anonymous (not verified)
16 Apr 2010 - 08:07
Anonymous's picture

what a strange remark anon 21:39.

'you know who you are'...what an odd thing to say. Are you perhaps needing a holiday?

Anonymous (not verified)
16 Apr 2010 - 08:08
Anonymous's picture

'bitter losers' - as opposed to what?

Anonymous (not verified)
16 Apr 2010 - 10:07
Anonymous's picture

I worked for a company in Chester all they wanted to do was build the comapny up to sell so if they didn't win business they would get ride of the creative department start fresh with a new department.

What they didn't understand they had never worked outside of Chester no planning or strategic skills and clients knew thay lacked the skills. But did they learn from it? no they didn't just blammed the Creative department

Anonymous (not verified)
16 Apr 2010 - 10:33
Anonymous's picture

What's anon 21:39 got against gay people?

Anonymous (not verified)
16 Apr 2010 - 11:00
Anonymous's picture

'Try being a boss then you will understand why!!!'

Still trying to understand this post???

Anonymous (not verified)
16 Apr 2010 - 13:09
Anonymous's picture

any agencies/bosses that spring to mind?

Anonymous (not verified)
16 Apr 2010 - 14:46
Anonymous's picture

names?

Anonymous (not verified)
17 Apr 2010 - 09:03
Anonymous's picture

Talking of that agency in chester the MD used those classic words " I know what the client likes"

Having said that, he also wore Blue Burberry ties for meetings, enough said.

Any other bosses wore the burberry?

Anonymous (not verified)
19 Apr 2010 - 17:52
Anonymous's picture

'Try being a boss then you will understand why!!!' - remember this was the first comment? Not heard any explanation yet?

Anonymous (not verified)
19 Apr 2010 - 17:53
Anonymous's picture

Excellent post anon 17:07...

21 Apr 2010 - 17:17
Bring back the Anon button's picture
41
comments

Love the stock shot used to represent angry management.

Even bankers don't dress that badly.

Write Your Comment

New to The Drum

You will be sent a verification email. Click on the link in the email to post your comment.

Tick to receive daily newsletter full of the latest news in creative marketing and media.
By checking this box you are agreeing to The Drum's website terms and conditions.

Don't miss out... Get your Advertising news by email

Directory Latest